TV Review: ‘Supergirl’ S1 EP1 “Pilot” – SERIES PREMIERE

Starring:  Melissa Benoist, Mehcad Brooks, Chyler Leigh, David Harewood, Calista Flockhart, Jeremy Jordan

Series created by:  Ali Adler, Greg Berlanti, Andrew Kreisberg

Episode Directed by:  Glen Winter / Written by:  Ali Adler, Greg Berlanti and Andrew Kreisberg / aired in the UK:  29/10/15

What’s this episode about?

Struggling to make her way as a reporter for National City’s Tribune newspaper, when an incident that endangers her sister’s life occurs Kara Danvers decides it’s finally time to embrace her Kryptonian heritage…

In review

Based on the DC Comics character and from the producers of Arrow and The Flash, Supergirl joins the increasingly crowded pantheon of current comic book television series (which those afore-mentioned shows aside, includes other DC based properties Gotham and the forthcoming Legends of Tomorrow) but this time, quite rightly, with a female lead.

An all too brief prologue explains Kara Zor-El’s arrival on Earth (having escaped from the destruction of her home planet, Krypton) which due to an excursion into the ‘Phantom Zone’ occurs twenty four years after her infant cousin, Kal-El landed.  With Kal-El having established himself as the titular Man of Steel himself, Superman, he leaves Kara in the care of the Danvers family to allow her to find her own path.

Fast forward to present day in National City and we see Kara Danvers (Melissa Benoist) struggling to forge a meaningful career at the Tribune newspaper headed up by the steely and cold hearted Cat Grant (a rather ‘catty’ turn from Calista Flockhart) and where Kara shares her woes and angsts with co-worker and best friend Winn (Jeremy Jordan).  Frustrated with the status quo, when her adoptive sister Alex (Chyler Leigh) is involved in a plane accident, Kara decides to embrace who she really is and utilise her abilities to help the innocent.

Melissa Benoist (formerly of Glee) is a likeable lead, deft at switching between both sides of her character, from displaying the happy-go-lucky bumbling unease as the bespectacled Kara Danvers to the strong willed determinations of the Girl of Steel (which Grant decides to name ‘Supergirl’, much to the annoyance of Kara who was hoping for something more along the lines of Superwoman).  She shares decent chemistry with her co-stars, with plenty of fun exchanges with Flockhart and Jordan and positive family ties with sister Alex (unfortunately we only get a glimpse of adoptive parents Jeremiah and Eliza Danvers – played by nineties TV Superman Dean Cain and one-time silver screen Supergirl Helen Slater, respectively).  The pilot of Supergirl also introduces us to another major character in the form of Superman’s best pal Jimmy – now taking himself more seriously as James – Olsen with a restrained yet promising and appropriately modern performance from Mehcad Brooks.

The Supergirl pilot’s key action sequence in which Kara leaps up, up and away(!) to save a crashing aeroplane is not entirely original, yet proves suitably tense and exhilarating (bolstered by some outstanding visual effects) and provides an event in which the Girl of Steel can be revealed to the world.  In contrast, the climactic showdown with villain Vartox (Owain Yeoman) comes off a little less refined and somewhat clunky…but I guess you can’t have it all?

Overall, the pilot for Supergirl is solidly entertaining with a tone largely reminiscent of the Christopher Reeve Superman films.  Whilst there are elements that will mainly appeal to a young adult demographic there’s still plenty of action and mythology to satisfy comic book fans.  There’s some necessary tip-toeing around the issue of Superman’s existence which despite the continuous references to “him”/”he” becoming a little tiresome, is generally well handled and the release of superpowered criminals from the Phantom Zone could prove either a blessing or a curse (remember those formulaic villain of the week episodes in the early days of Smallville?) but with a couple of neat twists and a likeable lead (and no less a strong female character for younger viewers to aspire to) there’s a good chance that Supergirl will fly.

The bottom line:  The pilot for Supergirl shows promise, despite some potentially formulaic elements there’s plenty of fun, action and comic book mythology to satisfy a varied audience.

Supergirl airs in the UK Thursday evenings on Sky One.  US viewers can catch it on CBS.

What did you think of the Supergirl pilot?  Share your thoughts below!

Melissa Benoist makes for a likeable lead in the new CBS series 'Supergirl'. Image belongs: CBS/DC Comics.

Melissa Benoist makes for a likeable lead in the new CBS series ‘Supergirl’. Image belongs: CBS/DC Comics.

9 thoughts on “TV Review: ‘Supergirl’ S1 EP1 “Pilot” – SERIES PREMIERE

  1. Awesome review, you sure have a way with words. I was truly entertained by your review; more than by the show sadly. I have to say that the pilot was a joke to me. It really felt like they were aiming for a teenage population. I still plan on giving the show a chance and see what it has in store for us, but compared to every other superhero show out there, Supergirl has a long way to catch up.

    – Lashaan

  2. Great review! I enjoyed the pilot for what it was. Totally agree Melissa Benoist is a likeable lead. I think casting Dean Cain and Helen Slater means we’ll be seeing more of them, perhaps in flashbacks or even present day. I’m looking forward to more Kryptonian flashbacks too. The pilot is a good start with lots of room for improvement.

    • Thanks! I think it may take several episodes to iron out the formulaic elements (a la The Flash) once the writers find their footing and develop the characters and ongoing story arcs.

  3. I love how you make tonal comparisons with the Christopher Reeve Superman films. I think you’re absolutely right, and I think it’s a smart move for the show-runners to take the series in that direction. I watched the entire episode with a dumb smile across my face…and I’m not ashamed to admit it.

    • Haha! Me too Gareth, I really enjoyed the second episode as well and will keep watching (at least for now). There’s definitely a charm to the series and the casting of Supergirl herself couldn’t have been more perfect.

  4. Pingback: Everybody’s Chattin + Trailer Spotlight: Finding Dory |

  5. Great review :). I found it fairly entertaining, but it’s not exactly my cup of tea (I’ll probably binge it all when the season is over). I’m a bit sad though that they basically gave her Superman’s origin story – in my opinion, it would have been far more interesting to do the New 52’s initial take on her, when she strongly disliked Earth and humans. I can understand why they didn’t want to do that take though – had to make sure it was child friendly and all…It was a decent start though I suppose (just admittedly not the one I wanted).

    • Thanks for the kind words! Yeah it was a good pilot but the series still needs to shake of it’s formulaic elements but I’m interested to see where it goes.

      You’re right though it would’ve been more interesting to have taken the New 52 approach with the character which would’ve given the series more dramatic potential.

      Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s