Comic Review: ‘Civil War II’ #8

Written by:  Brian Michael Bendis / pencilled by:  David Marquez

What’s it about?

As the visions of Ulysses become more intense, Tony Stark and Carol Danvers face off with the future of the entire superhero community at stake…

In review

After numerous delays, Marvel’s blockbuster event draws to a close with the extra-sized final issue of Civil War II.  Showing great promise in its first couple of issues, Civil War II quickly slid comfortably into a by-the-numbers comic event rhythm.  That being said, the event did produce some standout moments (the vision of Miles Morales’ Spider-Man killing Steve Rogers’ Captain America on the steps of Capitol Hill being particularly vivid and unnerving) and David Marquez’s art has elevated each instalment above mediocrity, but on the whole it failed to be anywhere near as ground-breaking as Mark Millar and Steve McNiven’s original Civil War.

In favour of this final issue, Brian Michael Bendis and David Marquez deliver some exciting edge-of-the-seat action with Bendis maintaining the tension and drama and Marquez presenting his amazingly detailed, blockbuster visuals as the conflict between Tony Stark/Iron Man and Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel reaches its climax.  As with previous issues the moral debate is touched upon but never fully explored (a shame considering the strength of some of Bendis’ other work) and ultimately taking a backseat to those aforementioned blockbuster elements.

Given that the delays Civil War II has faced meant its finale following the release of several relaunched ‘Marvel Now!’ titles, the conclusion – specifically the fate of Tony Stark – is unsurprising given what we’ve seen in Infamous Iron Man and Invincible Iron Man but it non-the-less still carries some dramatic weight as the path is paved for the future of the Marvel Universe.  Perhaps that’s where the problem lies, with the need to establish the status quo of Marvel’s latest line-wide shake-up it’s left less room from Brian Bendis to really delve into the commentary of Civil War II.

In the end, taken as a whole Civil War II was an enjoyable albeit undemanding blockbuster event that is unlikely to be heralded as a classic in years to come but may still be worthy of a revisit when the dust has settled.  It’s not the greatest story Marvel has delivered in recent years but it’s also far from the weakest.

The bottom line:  Whilst Civil War II ultimately failed to live up to the potential of its premise, this final issue succeeds in delivering some great moments of action and drama with a fitting conclusion that establishes the future of the Marvel U.

Civil War II #8 is published by Marvel Comics and is available in print and digital formats now.

Marvel's grand event comes to a close in the final issue of Civil War II (cover art by David Marquez).

Marvel’s grand event comes to a close in the final issue of Civil War II (cover art by David Marquez).

7 thoughts on “Comic Review: ‘Civil War II’ #8

  1. Great review. I was left more than a little underwhelmed by Civil War II #8, maybe its because it was delayed, or maybe its because Invincible Iron Man and Infamous Iron Man has already hinted about what happened to Stark. Civil War II looked great, fantastic art, but as an event, I think it failed to deliver on several fronts.

    • Yeah, it’s such a shame that CWII never really hit full-steam, even more so considering the creative talent involved. It may read better collected, thanks for checking out the review Paul!

  2. Pingback: Bye bye 2016! End of year recap & musings on favorite films we saw this year

  3. Great review, on a personal note after all the changes going on at Marvel Comics I was underwhelmed with their tentpole events like Civil War II. Based on what has happened in the mini-series, it didn’t do anything to change my mind, but maybe things will improve with the inevitable Civil War III.

    • Civil War III would be a terrible idea but you’re right that it’s more or less inevitable. CWII certainly could’ve been better but enjoyable enough on a basic entertainment level. Thanks for checking out the review!

  4. Great review! It’s not often that I see you “disappointed” in something you’ve read! 😛 I haven’t read anything related to Civil War 2 (although I do think I have the Free Comic Book Day issue #1). I did read Civil War and was quite surprised by how action-packed that was (totally different from what we got from the movie adaptation). Are there series or volumes you need to read before Civil War 2 to be able to fully understand the new dilemma? Or is it really a stand-alone storyarc?

    – Lashaan

    • Thank you my friend! I’d still say give Civil War II a go, on the whole it’s an entertaining (and visually gorgeous) read but ultimately doesn’t live up to the potential of it’s premise. I’t certainly not as groundbreaking or as compelling as the original CW.

      CW II is pretty accesible and I found it fairly self-contained so no need to check out any other volumes in the lead-up!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s