TV Review: ‘Legion’ S1 EP01 “Chapter 1”

Fox explore the more bizarre corners of the X-Men universe for their first X-based television series…

Starring:  Dan Stevens, Rachel Keller, Aubrey Plaza, David Selby, Hamish Linklater, Katie Aselton, Jean Smart

Series created by:  Noah Hawley

Written and directed by: Noah Hawley / aired in the UK : 09/02/2017

What’s it about?

David Haller has heard voices all his life but soon discovers that there may be more to his ‘condition’ than meets the eye…

Episode review

In partnership with Marvel TV, Legion sees Fox bring their live-action X-Men franchise to the small screen.  Developed by Fargo series creator Noah Hawley, Legion is based upon the Marvel Comics character David Haller, created by Chris Claremont and Bill Sienkiewicz who first appeared in New Mutants #25 (published in 1985).  Dan Stevens (Downton Abbey) plays Haller, a mental patient who throughout his life has been plagued by voices that he is starting to believe are real and has drawn the attention of the mysterious Brubaker (David Selby) and his interrogator (Hamish Linklater), who are interested in Haller’s telekinetic abilities and his potential as the most powerful mutant ever discovered.

From the outset it’s obvious that Legion is far less comic-y than its big screen brethren favouring a more restrained, less colourful and more cerebral approach reminiscent of a Netflix or HBO production.  Whilst fans of the X-Men comics universe may find that an initial disappointment, what unfolds in this series premiere is too compelling to ultimately ignore.  Via a series of flashbacks we learn of David’s increasingly tortured mental state from innocent childhood to teenage delinquency and his current plight as a resident of Clockwork Psychiatric Hospital where he is teased by the presence of people who may or may not be real, including his inseparable ‘pal’ Lenny (a suitably sardonic Aubrey Plaza).

Events become all the more unreal as David ‘meets’ Syd (Rachel Keller), a newly admitted patient that he quickly becomes captivated by.  To say much more would spoil things, but it’s this meeting that forms the basis of David’s present situation as he grapples with a loosening grip on ‘reality’.  As Haller, Stevens is magnetic with a melancholic, at times manic, performance that he deftly mixes with prominent shades of agitation, frustration and bewilderment intertwined with smatterings of black humour.  The supporting cast are all perfectly able in their roles but it’s Stevens that carries much of the proceedings as we’re left perplexed by the hallucinatory visualisation of this unusual story.

Written and directed by Hawley, “Chapter 1” is a predominately trippy experience that leaves the viewer in a similar predicament to the show’s central character, primarily in a state of almost maddening confusion, yet manages to leave you intrigued and hanging on for what’s next.  Hawley skilfully depicts the bizarre imaginings of his script, the interesting use of lighting, colour, camera angles, editing and digital effects (not to mention some rather spacey music cues by Jeff Russo) stringing together the non-linear construction of the narrative.  Whether future epsidoes will maintain this approach, to such a degree as it is here – and succeed – remains to be seen but it certainly proves effective for this series opener.

Legion comes off as a creative collision that feels something like One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest meets Being John Malkovich via Inception but ultimately is a strange brew that forms its own personality.  In fact, part of Legion’s unusual appeal is that its setting is at times vague, it’s apparently present day but some of the costumes and decor resemble a period closer to the sixties – a neat visual homage to the times of the original X-Men comics, maybe?

Despite the show being unconnected to Fox’s X-Men films and somewhat distanced from the Marvel comic books, “Chapter 1” still offers solid hints at the core elements of X-Men mythology as it touches on the themes of prejudice and fear of the unknown that stretches back to the stories created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby in the early 1960s.  Given David Haller’s connection to a certain wheelchair-bound mutant Professor in the X-Men comics universe it wouldn’t be unwelcome to see more ties into the overall mythology, whether subtle or not.

If there’s any real drawback to Legion it’s that it’s lack of lucidity can be challenging but perhaps that’s part of the plan, to lure us in and become invested in a series that could prove to be unique and addictively entertaining?

The bottom line:  Legion debuts with a complex, chaotic, weird and – in moments – quite funny premiere for a superhero based series that could prove a refreshing addition to an ever popular and increasingly exploited genre.

Legion airs in the UK Thursday evenings on Fox.  U.S. viewers can catch it Wednesdays on FX.

Insane or not? Dan Stevens is Davidd Haller in Fox's 'Legion', based on the Marvel Comics character.

Insane or not? Dan Stevens is David Haller in Fox’s ‘Legion’, based on the Marvel Comics character.

What did you think of the Legion season premiere?  Share your thoughts below!

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “TV Review: ‘Legion’ S1 EP01 “Chapter 1”

  1. I enjoyed the first episode of Legion, it was certainly very different, and beautifully filmed. Love the slightly retro look as well, certainly very interested in seeing how this series develops.

      • I’m sure they will explore the original storylines of the character as well, I think its good how they’ve embraced how much potential Legion has, and are really going for something very fresh and different.

  2. Brooo, you make everything sound sooooooo much better with your amazing reviews. And to top it off, you had to say “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest meets Being John Malkovich via Inception”. How can one decide to skip a show that reminds you of all three of those movies? 😀 I’ve been meaning to check out how Legion would turn out since the first day they mentioned about creating a TV show for the X-Men. Don’t know if I’m going to wait for more episodes to come out to binge this or add it to my weekly viewing (with all those DC TV shows). By the way, what do you think the other X-Men show will be like?

    Excellent review, bro.

    – Lashaan

    • Cheers good sir! I know what you mean about fitting stuff in between all the DC shows but I just had to squeeze this one in…it’s only eight episodes so should be OK! It’s defo worth a look. I’m certainly looking forward to the other X-show even though there are very few details about it at the moment. I think it will be more of an action heavy series with a more comic-y superpower element to it which I think would be a perfect companion to the mindbending weirdness of Legion. What are your hopes for that one?

      • I actually have the feeling that it will have a similar vibe to Gotham (TV show), especially because it’s Fox. Probably have a bunch of easter eggs and insert some never-before-seen origin stories to characters fans would love to see. I don’t know if it’ll acknowledge the existence of Legion, but if Legion acknowledges the existence of all the X-Men movies that have come out so far, then Fox’s X-Men show will probably fit right in, somewhere in a close future to the latest X-Men movie we got. It’ll look a little like all the Netflix Marvel shows, you know?

        – Lashaan

      • I have similar thoughts my friend! Apparently it will be unconnected to Legion but will be ‘kind of’ set within the same universe as the movies…but don’t expect Hugh Jackman or Michael Fassbender to cameo haha!

      • If Jackman were to ever appear again (after Logan), it would probably HAVE to be with Deadpool for the sake of pleasing thousands of fans!! 😛

        P.S. I don’t know if you were aware of it, but yesterday, for Valentine’s Day, we had a special post go live with the purpose of thanking some of our favourite followers. Obviously, you were among them! Thank you for your all your impressive reviews and for ALWAYS (no pressure 😉 ) dropping by whenever there’s a post related to something related to comics/a classic novel you’ve read that! It’s ALWAYS a pleasure to see you around and hearing your thoughts. 🙂

        https://bookidote.wordpress.com/2017/02/14/what-type-of-blogger-are-you-v-day-special/

        – Lashaan

      • I’m a little bit behind with your most recent posts but will certainly catch up very soon! Thank very much for the kind words, I very much enjoy reading your blog posts and adding to the discussion. Likewise, a big THANKS to your good self for regularly dropping by and sharing your thoughts which I always appreciate and look forward to 🙂

  3. This was one trippy premiere but I really enjoyed it. It seemed so cinematic and directed in a non-conventional way. I cannot think of The Who’s “Happy Jack” in the same way again. It wasn’t a perfect pilot but it had me hooked at the end. Hopefully, the rest of the program will maintain the standards exhibited in the pilot.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s