Film Review: ‘X-Men: Dark Phoenix’

It’s farewell to the ‘First Class’ as Fox’s X-Men series draws to a close…

X-Men Dark Phoenix (a)

The finale to 20th Century Fox’s Marvel film series – ‘X-Men: Dark Phoenix’ (credit: 20th Century Fox/Marvel).


Spoiler-free review

Starring:  James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, Nicholas Hoult, Sophie Turner, Jessica Chastain

Directed and written by:  Simon Kinberg / 114 minutes

What’s it about?

Whilst on a mission to rescue the crew of a stricken space shuttle, X-Men team member Jean Grey encounters a mysterious cosmic force which amplifies her psychokinetic powers to dangerous and uncontrollable levels…

In review

Serving as the finale of 20th Century Fox’s mainline X-Men film series (although troubled spin-off New Mutants is still, presently, set for an eventual theatrical release) – the rights to the property now with Marvel Studios following Disney’s Fox acquisition – X-Men: Dark Phoenix follows 2016’s X-Men: Apocalypse with a plot once again based on the iconic comic book storyline previously adapted (superbly) for the 1990s X-Men animated series and incorporated (not so successfully) into Fox’s original X-trilogy capper, X-Men: The Last Stand (released back in 2006).

Written and directed by long-term X-Men writer and producer Simon Kinberg, the 90’s-set X-Men: Dark Phoenix (simply known as just ‘Dark Phoenix’ in the U.S.) isn’t the rousing, wholly satisfying finale the series deserved but nor is it a crashing failure.  It doesn’t hit the heights of previous entries First Class or Days of Future Past but is comfortably superior to The Last Stand and a fair leap above X-Men Origins: Wolverine, arguably the franchise’s lowest point.  Aiming for a more grounded and character driven focus than the divisive Apocalypse, Dark Phoenix is unlikely to sway viewers left unimpressed by Bryan Singer’s X-sequel but it’s a laudable approach and Kinberg’s script packs an emotional punch whilst the sombre and dark tone lends some emotional maturity and tension to the proceedings.  The only issue here is that it doesn’t feel as though we’ve been given enough time to truly care about the newer X-Men team members introduced in Apocalypse and besides Sophie Turner’s Jean Grey they don’t actually get a whole lot to do in Dark Phoenix beyond playing their part in the action.  There’s also some drag in the pacing during the second act due to the slow-burn narrative, with much of the action saved for the finale which together with that desire for a more restrained and personal approach can leave Dark Phoenix lacking a larger sense of adventure and excitement, something First Class and Days of Future Past were able to accomplish whilst still delivering on character.

Cast performances are generally strong, Sophie Turner (Game of Thrones) does a solid enough job with a lot of dramatic weight to carry as Jean Grey, unable to control the temptation and danger of the Phoenix force descends into turmoil.  Returning First Class alumni Jennifer Lawrence is suitably dour and weary as Raven/Mystique and fellow first generation X-Man Nicholas Hoult has a poignant and contemplative turn as Hank McCoy/Beast.  Interstellar’s Jessica Chastain makes for a sinister if underdeveloped villain, her manipulation of the increasingly fragile Jean and her Phoenix force heightened powers providing high stakes and a cause for our heroes to rally against.

X-Men Dark Phoenix (b)

Tye Sheridan returns as Cyclops (credit: 20th Century Fox/Marvel).

Again though, it’s James McAvoy and Michel Fassbender – Charles Xavier/Professor X and Erik Lensherr/Magneto respectively – who are the standouts and both actors are provided with some good material, especially McAvoy as Xavier grapples with fracturing friendships, a reluctance to acknowledge his mistakes and an uncertain future for the X-Men and consequentially, mutantkind.  Sadly, despite having roles to play in the action, Alexandra Shipp’s Storm, Evan Peters’ Quicksilver and Kodi Smit-McPhee’s Nightcrawler are not afforded a large enough presence for the majority of the film and tend to withdraw into the background with no significant character arcs of their own.  Tye Sheridan’s Scott Summers/Cyclops fares better but, again, there hasn’t really been time enough for the actors and their respective characters to grow beyond their debuts in X-Men: Apocalypse.

Making his feature film directorial debut, Simon Kinberg handles it fairly competently – keeping things level and focused in the more character-driven scenes whilst skilfully staging the action which aside from the initial space rescue mission (accompanied by some nicely atmospheric music from score composer Hans Zimmer), includes a climactic battle aboard a speeding train that ramps up the tension as Dark Phoenix reaches its denouement.  Despite the months of extensive re-shoots, Kinberg’s film hangs together in a coherent manner.

So, although Dark Phoenix isn’t a runaway hit it’s not a disastrous misfire either resulting in an entertaining diversion that doesn’t live up to the high-points of the X-Men franchise or it’s potential as a grand finale but is a stronger take on a beloved story arc with some decent character beats and an action-packed final act.

The bottom line:  Not the train wreck it was feared to be nor the epic final chapter it could’ve been, X-Men: Dark Phoenix is still a reasonably enjoyable time for those willing to give it a chance.

X-Men: Dark Phoenix is in cinemas now.

13 thoughts on “Film Review: ‘X-Men: Dark Phoenix’

  1. Great review! I’ve not had a chance to see Dark Phoenix yet as I’ve been busy, but I hope to see it soon. Sounds like its not quite the disaster everyone was expecting, which is good. I’ll look forward to seeing it.

      • Thanks, I will. I have enjoyed most of the X-Men films, so been intrigued to see how they finish the saga now everything is moving over to the MCU. Dark Phoenix sure sounds different from Apocalypse, which I didn’t enjoy much TBH, so hopefully Dark Phoenix will deliver a good finale.

  2. I have to admit I don’t really have a burning desire to see Dark Phoenix because from what I heard, it’s a real love-it-or-hate-it experience. I think I’ll probably wait for it to appear on Netflix before I see it. Then again, I also didn’t see Apocalypse, so maybe that would be in order first.

    • It’s funny because I’d probably suggest renting it to most people unless they really feel they need to see it right away. Apocalypse seems to be more and more unloved as time goes on but I actually thought it was okay, but Dark Phoenix is quite a different film.

  3. I honestly wasn’t excited about this movie at all. I sort of hated Apocalypse and nothing about it wanted me to have hope in Fox’s franchise. Even the first teaser trailer for Dark Phoenix had me level of excitement so low that I thought that the movie would just go straight-to-bluray!

    It’s a bit unfortunate that they didn’t dose the screen time properly to give more characters time to shine and allow the viewer to feel emotional-attached with them. At least some of the actors, like McAvoy and Fassbender continue to deliver quality performances in their individual roles.

    I think this will also be a movie I’ll be watching once it hits bluray or Netflix. So what’s the next theatrical release you’ll be checking out? Spider-Man? 😀 I actually look forward to finding out what Marvel plans on doing past Spider-Man and what kind of after-credit scene it would include. I do hope we’ll someday get Hardy’s Venom crossover to Spider-Man’s universe in the 3rd installment.

    Again, fantastic honest review as always! When’s the next superhero comic book review to come from you, bro?

    • I think it may be one for you to glance at when it’s available to rent then Lashaan…but if you hated Apocalypse (which I actually didn’t mind) I’m not sure Dark Phoenix will win you over, but it is quite a different film in tone and execution.

      Yep, I’ll be checking Spider-Man when it comes out next month. It’ll be interesting to see how that deals with Endgame and sets things going forward.

      In terms of comic reviews, I actually have a review of Batman: Year One drafted so will be posting that at some point in the coming weeks so stay tuned!

  4. Very nice review that aptly sums up how I feel about this concluding film.

    Dark Phoenix is not this horrible abomination but we deserved a better film considering how much Last Stand mishandled the Dark Phoenix yarn.

    The film has its pluses to be sure like many of the performances and some of the set pieces. At least we have a conclusion to the First Class X-Men films that is somewhat competent.

  5. This review is a bit more positive than others I have read about this film. Fox have been very hit and miss with the X-Men franchise. Let’s see how Marvel themselves handle it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s